This post may contain affiliate links. Read the disclosure policy for more info.

Last fall, I kept reaching for the same sweaters again and again—proof that the classics never fail.

Today, I’m sharing my 13 most-worn sweaters from last year, plus exactly how I’m styling them for fall 2024. Whether you’re looking to build a capsule wardrobe or simply want to see which knits are truly worth it, you’ll find something for every style and budget here. P.S. If you want my latest picks for this season, don’t miss my new post: 6 Cozy Fall Sweaters You’ll Want To Wear With Every Outfit This Season. When I choose sweaters for my wardrobe, I always gravitate toward timeless pieces in classic colors—think ivory, navy, khaki, camel, and chocolate—with simple, elegant silhouettes. I also pay close attention to fabric, opting for cashmere, merino, and chunky knits that feel as luxurious as they look. And, of course, wearability is key: if I can style a sweater at least three different ways, it earns a spot in my rotation.

1. L.L.Bean Fisherman Sweater

This classic fisherman's knit from LL Bean is one of my absolute essentials for fall. The chunky cable knit and ivory shade make it endlessly versatile and flattering—exactly what I reach for when I want to feel both cozy and pulled together. L.L.Bean Signature Cotton Fisherman Sweater, Crewneck

2. Amazon Cable Knit Sweater

Sometimes, the quality on Amazon really surprises me, and this piece has become a true staple in my wardrobe. Amazon Essentials Winter Long-Sleeve Cable Knit

3. Navy Fisherman Knit

This navy blue cable knit is one of my favorite classic sweaters for fall. The rich, deep hue feels perfectly seasonal and adds instant polish to any outfit. I find that navy is such an underrated color for autumn—it’s as versatile as black but a bit softer and more elevated. L.L.Bean Signature Cotton Fisherman Sweater, Crewneck

4. Navy Cable Knit (Amazon)

This Amazon fisherman’s sweater is the same classic style as the ivory version above, just in a deep, elegant navy blue. I love finding pieces like this because you get that timeless cable knit look and versatile silhouette in multiple colorways. Amazon Essentials Winter Long-Sleeve Cable Knit

5. Camel Roll-Neck Sweater (Amazon)

This Amazon roll neck is one of those rare sweaters I reach for year after year, not just in fall, but all through winter as well. I have it in several colors, but the camel shade is my absolute favorite for the autumn season. The silhouette is classic and incredibly flattering, and the knit is surprisingly soft. Amazon Essentials Classic-Fit Lightweight Long-Sleeve Turtleneck

6. Burgundy Roll-Neck Sweater (Amazon)

Burgundy is easily one of my most-worn colors in the fall, right after all my favorite browns. This Amazon roll neck sweater in burgundy has become a staple in my closet—I wore it on repeat last autumn, and I know it will be a favorite again this season. The color is both classic and striking, adding a beautiful depth to any outfit. Amazon Essentials Classic-Fit Lightweight Long-Sleeve Turtleneck

7. Ralph Lauren Rib-Knit Roll Neck

If you’re like me and have a soft spot for all things Ralph Lauren, you’ll appreciate this rib knit roll neck just as much as my beloved Amazon version. There’s something about the fit of this sweater—it’s a bit more tailored and form-fitting, which instantly elevates any outfit and gives you that classic Ralph Lauren polish. The camel shade is a staple for fall and looks just as beautiful layered under coats as it does worn on its own. Lauren Ralph Lauren Ribbed Turtleneck Sweater

8. Ivory Vintage Cardigan (Amazon)

This Belle Poque cardigan from Amazon is by far my most-worn fall sweater—I honestly wear it almost every single day, and not just in fall but throughout the year. The flared hem and tailored fit create the most elegant silhouette, instantly making any outfit look more polished and feminine. I love how it defines the waist, but still feels incredibly comfortable and cozy. Belle Poque Women Vintage Cardigan Sweater

9. Brown Crew Neck Knit

This classic piece was one of my most worn layering sweaters because it's thinner and perfect to wear under fall jackets and coats. The color is absolutely perfect and beautiful, and I wore this crew neck sweater a lot with my favorite Target dark wash jeans. Relaxed Crewneck Sweater Similar style: ANRABESS Lightweight Crewneck Sweater

10. Pointelle Knit Sweater

This Beautiful sweater is perfect for a warmer fall day or if you are living in a warmer place. The scalloped detail and delicate design make this such a unique and special sweater. I loved pairing this sweater with brown bottoms, such as my favorite mini skirt. Madewell Cotton Crewneck Sweater Similar style: Pointelle Knit Sweater

11. Amazon Fisherman Cable Knit

But because it is soft and warm, it makes a very nice fall sweater that I wore almost every day last year Amazon Essentials Long Sleeve Fisherman Cable

12. Chloé Fair Isle Knit

A fairisle knit has always been a classic and will always be a classic. This Fairisle knit sweater from Chloe is something I wore last year almost every single day. And have been wearing every day this fall season so far. Alpaca Blend Fair Isle Sweater Similar style: CIDER Fair Isle Wool Blend Sweater

13. Amazon Crewneck Sweater

This Amazon find is the epitome of a classic Fairisle knit. Its richness in color and perfect balance of autumnal neutral hues and pops of color is really what makes this piece truly special. But let's be honest… nobody would know that. Amazon Essentials Crewneck Sweater

How I would Style it This Year: I love the contrast between white and brown in the fall, so I would probably wear it with either white or ivory jeans to create this beautiful contrast.

Shopping for a Western-chic girl too? My Western Chic Gift Guide has the buckle belts, boots and cozy layers I’ve tagged on LTK this season.

(I’m also the founder of American Darling, Western chic loungewear. Nothing from it is linked in this post.)

• Western Chic Gift Guide